The Third Act Fail

When I was a Junior in college I wrote my first short screenplay about a kid driving an urn of ashes across the country.  It was a terrible, terrible piece of writing that featured classic screenwriting 101 bullshit that our friend Garryt (whom we mentioned last week) had to read.  Out loud.  In class.  Poor bastard.

At one point I think my frustration at trying to piece things together breaks through the fourth wall in the form of a line of dialogue that does nothing to advance the script:

Apparently Airplane was on?  What's our vector, Victor?

Apparently Airplane was on? What’s our vector, Victor?

“Don’t really care.”  – Yep.  I wrote that.  This script preceded Scott Thompson’s class, so consider him free from blame on this one.

The saving grace of the whole thing, to toot my own horn, was that the story ended in a way that you did not see coming.

This was mainly because I’d written the ending first.

The rest of the story was lost because it all had to culminate to this point.  I had to plan the trajectory backwards.  It became a matter of connecting the dots simply to get to the ending.

And I’m terrible at connecting the dots.

Looks right to me?

So it’s going to be a monster movie?

The reason I bring up my horrible screenplay is that this is one of those rare occurrences where the cart can come before the horse and it is totally okay.

(It’s totally not okay, but had I given the backwards building process more attention and care…who knows?  It could have had more potential.)

And if you have a collaborator, so much the better.

Lately I’ve been witnessing that movies have no idea what the fuck they’re doing with their own last act.  The third act barely coheres to the other two.  Perhaps I’m better at embellishing other people’s stories, but you can’t just cop out on an ending.

That’s like you paying me to go on my rollercoaster with the last 3rd of track not done.


The souvenir snapshot is going to be fantastic.


Doesn’t seem too fair, does it?

"Bet you folks enjoyed those first loops though, huh?  Those were good times!"

“Bet you folks enjoyed those first loops though, huh? 

For an example of what I mean I’m offering you eight movies that completely go off the rails by the third act, and never fully recover.  I’ve already felt that I’ve written too much, so I’ll find the exact moment that (in my opinion) the movie jumped the track and take a picture.

Or somewhere relatively close to the moment that the whole movie unraveled.

Spoilers ahead.  You’ve been warned.  I’ll try to give as little context as possible.

And for what it’s worth, I wanted to like these movies more.

•  The Dark Knight Rises (2012):  I have to get this one out of the way first because 95% of the time I love Christopher Nolan’s work.

Waking back to Gotham

Waking back to Gotham


•  Oblivion (2013):  Twinsies.

Jack meets Jack.  And the movie doesn't really know what do from there.

And the movie doesn’t really know what do from there.

•  Robocop (2014):  Breaking protocol.

Solving my own murder, because science.

Solving my own murder, because future security cameras plot-spackle.

•  War of the Worlds (2005):  This incredibly unnecessary scene.

What the hell, Tim Robbins?

Also why the hell, Tim Robbins?

•  Terminator Salvation (2009):  When we’ve been waiting for the story to catch up with itself.

You just realized you were a robot.  We all knew hours ago.

You just realized you were a robot. We all knew hours ago.

•  The Simpsons Movie (2007):  Pretty much everything Alaska.

Tom Hanks' cameo did what it could.

Tom Hanks’ cameo did what it could.

•  Hancock (2008):  Connected space lover heroes slapstick stupidity.

What the hell just happened here?


•  Looper (2012):  The damn kid.


(Not a burp)

All I ask, future screenwriters of America, is to actually flesh out your story and know where it goes and ends before making it get too out of hand (looking at you too, tv shows).  It’s cool to come up with the ending and work backwards if you have the time and the care.  But it’s mostly about the care.

Huge credit due to writers who can maintain a consistent and solid three act process.

(Oh were you looking for this?)

(Oh were you looking for this?)


About Eric

Frankie “The Red Panda” Funkaducciola RIP Uncle Prime
This entry was posted in Assholes, General Ranting, Lists, Movies, MUTOD, Sci-Fi and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s